<

Open Nav
Sign In

1955 Caldecott Medal Winners and Honor Books

< Caldecott Medal and Honor Books


REVIEW TEAM FAVORITE

Cinderella, or The Little Glass Slipper

Illustrated by: Marcia Brown

Medal Winner

Sandy Hall

Reviewed by: Sandy Hall
Recommended age: Ages 4 and up
Also read and recommended by: Jeannette Tulis, Sherry Early

Charles Perrault's French version of Cinderella is here retold and illustrated by Marcia Brown. Cinderella is a fairy tale told in various versions across time and cultures, but Perrault's is a favorite and the most well-known. 

The importance of the power of story for children was believed by Marcia Brown, and her writing of Cinderella shows that. She tells of the goodness of the young girl despite being mistreated by her step-sisters. Brown's illustrations for this book, done in soft pastels and ink, portray the fairy tale well. The drawings throughout the book are varied: some spanning a two-page spread, some full-page pictures, and sometimes the text wrapping around them in a variety of ways. 

It would be interesting to also read The Egyptian Cinderella by Shirley Climo, Cendrillon: A Cajun Cinderella by Sheila Collins, or Smoky Mountain Rose: An Appalachian Cinderella by Alan Schroeder and compare this fairy tale as told by different cultures. 



REVIEW TEAM FAVORITE

Marguerite De Angeli's Book of Nursery & Mother Goose Rhymes

By: Marguerite de Angeli

Honor

Sandy Hall

Reviewed by: Sandy Hall
Recommended age: Ages 4 and up
Also read and recommended by: Lara Lleverino, Sherry Early

With 376 rhymes and over 260 illustrations, Marguerite de Angeli's Book of Nursery and Mother Goose Rhymes is an extensive volume of many well-known and more obscure nursery rhymes. The older I get, the more I see how few children know these rhymes which is so sad. I sing many to my grandchildren like "Hickory, dickory, dock" and "The eency weency spider climbed the water spout." Educationally, I believe these nursery rhymes are helpful in getting children to understand rhyming words as well as rhythm. Many of the rhymes are ones I have never heard before, short two-line rhymes as well as more extensive ones. 

The illustrations by de Angeli are so lovely and idyllic. Animals, children, and scenery are carefully paired with the rhymes. Many of the illustrations are pencil drawings scattered across the pages, and every 10 to 12 pages, there is a full-page, full-color drawing as well as a smaller vignette drawing on the opposite page of the two-page spread. Soft-hued colors fill the drawings of beautiful country scenes. 

I think this special book should be read and enjoyed by anyone who has little ones. The sound of the words, the lilt of the rhythm, and the touching illustrations will be loved, enjoyed, remembered, and treasured.

In the forward to the book, Marguerite describes her surprise when she realized that she had actually drawn her own family as the illustration for this rhyme,

"God bless the master of this house,

Likewise the mistress too.

And all the little children 

That round the table go;

And all your kin and kinsmen,

That dwell both far and near; 

I wish you a Merry Christmas,

And a Happy New Year."


The Thanksgiving Story

By: Alice Dalgliesh
Illustrated by: Helen Sewell

Honor
NOT REVIEWED

This is a book to read aloud to children when they first want to know why we have Thanksgiving Day. Children a little older may read it themselves.

The story tells of one family on the Mayflower, of their hardships on the voyage and during their first winter. It tells, too, of joy in the arrival of their new baby, of spring in their new home, of planting, harvest, and the giving of thanks.

ALICE DALGLIESH has written the text so that it carries something of the feeling of a great enterprise, something of the struggle for food and shelter—yet always keeps close to family life and so to the children reading it. HELEN SEWELL has kept the same spirit in her distinctive pictures which have much of the character of American primitive paintings.

From the dust jacket


Wheel On The Chimney

By: Margaret Wise Brown
Illustrated by: Tibor Gergely

Honor
NOT REVIEWED

First there was one stork, then there were two. They built their nest on a wheel that the farmer had bound to the chimney. There they raised their family of two white silent small storks, and the farmer was glad because storks bring good luck to the house on which they build their nest.

In lovely rhythmic words, such as only Margaret Wise Brown could write, we follow the storks on their great flight south, to the depths of Africa where they spend the winter; and we watch them as, impelled by some secret inner knowledge, they fly north when spring comes to these lands. There they build a nest on a wheel on the chimney, and the story starts all over again.

Tibor Gergely lives in the United States, but he came from the land where storks build nests on farmers' chimneys. For many years he wanted to do a picture book about these beautiful bird and, when the author saw his pictures, she wanted to write the text. So we have a memorable book that has the sweep and strength of the brave storks' flight.

From the dust jacket